WPCi 8j}QZJ1=o[6Q=E -00yd{2ϞWpyXg0-˵N@^iIIO_!ݾD/1o6 ԤςnDE/̜Cr뾑E .N Td'I25 Y=T~Tq`5ɗ~Ov;tY oZ)# >U.I %w 0(}U>w@4#7FLNf! a# 7 b= f a ` 0D UNY  b. UN    U. U.5 0DUNbJUNX B 0DUNUNU  h2 hHP LaserJet IIIHPPCL5A,,,,,,0 <6X9`+CourierX($(\  p`&Times New Roman n[oIpwxy[zD{I|t"3|x  ' PBMS 4-17-97 Summary , CROSS } )  XXXX%~ XXELABPBMSSubcommitteeMeetingTABLE AQ X #'    $XXXXAttachmentA TABLE B V )   'XX/d/E  LABPBMSSubcommitteeMeeting      1  ڀof4     x  April   ((#((#(#(#17,1997(3$ !  (9 Z 6Times New Roman Regular } )  XXXX%~ XXELABPBMSSubcommitteeMeeting X #'    %XXXX AttachmentB (9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularQ* )   'XXELABPBMSSubcommitteeMeeting      1  ڀof4     x  April  17,1997<6X9`+Courier<6X9`+Courier y *    XXXX%~ XXApril17,1997(3$ !  (9 Z 6Times New Roman Regular of 46Times New Roman Regular d(3$ !  (9 Z 6Times New Roman Regular(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularH*            <@  3@TABLE A (s@@@i@@`@@@i@r@   `k@   r@   @   @TABLE B !  _aw wwwaaa___mm^%  ^m 7!!dXXd7m@>>#]\%  \]^]%  ]^ XXXXSummaryofthe  @ ELABPBMSSubcommitteeTeleconference@#April17,1997 ThePerformanceBasedMeasurementSystems(PBMS)SubcommitteeoftheEnvironmentalLaboratoryAdvisoryBoard(ELAB)convenedbyteleconferenceonApril17,1997,at12:30p.m.Themeetingwasledbyitschair,Dr.KathyHilligofBASFCorporation.ThepurposeofthismeetingwastodefineperformancebasedmethodsandmeasurementsystemsandtodiscusswhatϜwouldhappentomakePerformanceBasedMeasurementSystemsacceptabletoallstakeholders.TheseitemswerecontinuedfromtheMarch6,1997teleconferenceagenda.AlistofactionitemsisprovidedinAttachmentAandalistofparticipantsisgiveninAttachmentB.Ms.HilligopenedthemeetingbyaskingiftheCommitteemembershadanyobjectionstothewordingofRecommendation#3, ELABrecommendsthatbeforeEPApromulgatesaregulation,itmustdemonstrateanddocumentthatMeasurementQualityObjectives(MQOs)areachievableusingavailablemeasurementtechnologyandRecommendation#4, EPAmustdemonstratethatanyneworrevisedregulatorymeasurementrequirementsareachievableonsamplesthatrepresentthesamelevelofanalyticalchallengeasthematrixforwhichtheregulationisintended.(Ideally,thiswouldbesamplesoftheactualmatrixtobemonitored,asdefinedbytheregulation.)TheCommitteemembersapprovedtherecommendationsaswritten.e֛eTheCommitteehadextensivediscussionsonthedifferencebetweenperformancebasedmethodsandperformancebasedmeasurementsystems.Mr.DavidFriedmanistofurnishMs.JeanneMourrainacopyofadefinitionprovidedbyJoeSlaytonandshe,inturn,willmakethisavailabletotheCommittee.Ms.MimiUhlfelderclarifiedherunderstandingofwhatthedifferenceinthedefinitionswerebystating, PerformanceBasedMethodsareacriteriayouhavetomeettostillbeabletosaythatyoudidthatmethodnumberversusPerformanceBasedMeasurementSystemwherethecriteriaarespecifiedforthemeasurementanditdoesnotmatterwhatmethodyouuse.Ms.MourrainreadtheNELACdefinitionforPerformanceBasedMeasurementSystem(PBMS)whichis, asetofprocesseswhereinthedataqualityneeds,mandatesorlimitationsofaprogramorprojectarespecifiedandserveasacriteriaforselectingappropriatemethodstomeetthoseneedsinacosteffectivemanner.TheCommitteemembersaretolookatthethreedefinitionstoseeifoneofthemisclearand,ifnot,trytoclarifyadefinitionbythenextteleconference.IndiscussingtheagendaitemonwhatneedstohappentomakePerformanceBasedMeasurementSystemsacceptabletoallstakeholders,Ms.HilligstatedthatAlVerstuyfthadsuggestedthatmemberslookattheMarch28OfficeofWaterFederalRegister,ProposedRuleonStreamlining.Mr.DavidFriedmanistosendCommitteemembershiscommentsonthestepsneededtosatisfyallstakeholders.Adiscussionofthedefinitionof matrixensued.Mr.LarryLaFleurstatedthathelikethedefinitionfurnishedbyMr.Friedman(previouslyprovidedintheMarch6,1997minutes)butfeltfurtherclarificationwasneededonwhatbehaviorwearetalkingabout.Afternoagreementwasreachedonthedefinitionof matrix,theCommitteeagreedtocontinuethediscussionatthenext T,'+ meeting.Ms.Hilligwillpollmembersastowhichdate,May19,20or21isbestforthenextϜteleconference.MembersaretocontactMs.Hilligwiththedatesonwhichtheywillbeavailable.̀   ` Мo                  AttachmentAopp@$n nActionItems d @ ELABPBMSSubcommitteeTeleconference@#April17,1997n n < *w " ddd Xdd Xdd X(#(#w,dd ,dd ,Sdd +      @<<4Name  x  @' Action  x  @<~ DateCompleted  x  DavidFriedman&JeanneMourrain     Mr.FriedmanwillfurnishMs.MourrainacopyofJoeSlaytonsdefinitionofPerformanceBasedMeasurementSystems.Ms.MourrainwillfurnishthisdefinitiontotheCommitteemembers.  D      AllCommitteeMembers    AllCommitteemembersshouldreadthethreedefinitionsofPerformanceBasedMethodsandPerformanceBasedMeasurementSystemstodecideifoneisclearenoughtosubmitortrytoclarifyadefinition.Thisshouldbedonebythenextmeeting.  `   (  DavidFriedman  D Mr.FriedmanwillfurnishtheCommitteemembershisideasonwhatneedstohappentomakePerformanceBasedMeasurementSystemsacceptabletoallstakeholders.     D AllCommitteeMembers  t  AllCommitteemembersneedtoreadtheMarch28issueoftheFederalRegisterontheOfficeofWatersproposedruleonstreamliningandalsothedefinitionof matrix.  L$ М  $% AllCommitteeMembers   T' AllCommitteemembersaretocontactMs.Hilligwiththedatesonwhichtheywillbeavailabletomeet(May19,20or21).  !@* Л h+  Мxx  #H, z          zy y{        AttachmentB{||% & @dd LISTOFPARTICIPANTS d @ ELABPBMSubcommitteeTeleconference@#April17,1997y y < *w"dddd dd Sdd " (#(#w,dd , dd , dd +     @JJ4Name  x  @#Affiliation  x  @8Telephones  x  TXXKathyHillig   Chair   X  BASFCorporation     Tel:3132465334Fax:3132465226Email:hilligk@npol.southgate.basfcorp.com     MikeConlon  t LabStrategyGroup  t Tel:7039131314Fax:7039131314Email:  `  DavidFriedman(Invited)  |  USEPA  T  Tel:2022603535Fax:2022604346Email:firedman.david@epamail.epa.gov  @  LarryLaFleur  4 NCASI  4 Tel:5417528801Fax:5417528806Email:llafleur@wcrcncasi.org    CynthiaLee  x AnalyticalServicesLaboratory  x Tel:5029626400Fax:5029626411Email:  " JeanneMourrain,DesignatedFederalOfficer  |% USEPA,NERLResearchTrianglePark  ' Tel:9195411120Fax:9195414101Email:mourrainjeanne@epamail.epa.gov  |* TonyPagliaro  8+ ACIL  8, Tel:2028875872Fax:2028870021Email:acil@ix.netcom.com  \/ JerryParr(Absent)   x1 QuanterraEnvironmentalService   2 Tel:3034216611Fax:3034679136Email:jerryparr@msn.com  !<5 JerryThoma(Absent)  #X7 EnvironmentalHealthLaboratories  "8 Tel:2192334777Fax:2192338207Email:  $; MimiUhlfelder  %t< EALaboratories  %t= Tel:3017714920Fax:3017714407Email:mmu@eaeng.mhs.compuserve.com  `' @ AlVerstuyft  (T"A AmcPetroInst.  (T"B Tel:5102423403Fax:5102425320Email:awve@chevron.com  @*#E CarolynCrossRecorder  ( USEPA  d Tel:9195413151Fax:9195414101    Email:crosscarolyn@epamail.epa.gov l+&K Л