Confidential Business Information
- What can TSCA 8(e) submitters claim as “confidential business information” (CBI)?
- EPA Is Limiting CBI, Reviewing Claims
- Support Information for Confidentiality Claims
What can TSCA 8(e) Submitters Claim as “Confidential Business Information” (CBI)?
Submitters may claim confidentiality for proprietary information within a Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) 8(e) submission but should submit a detailed written explanation to substantiate all confidential business information (CBI) claims. Also, submitters must submit a sanitized copy of the submission from which confidential information has been deleted to be placed in the TSCA Public Docket. More information is available below and in Part IX. of the June 3, 2003, Federal Register notice (68 FR 33140).
EPA Is Limiting CBI, Reviewing Claims
In 2010, as part of EPA Administrator Lisa P. Jacksonís commitment to increase transparency and the publicís access to chemical information, EPA issued a new policy, saying it will deny, with limited exceptions, confidentiality claims for the identity of chemicals in health and safety studies under TSCA. EPA also launched a review of more than an estimated 16,000 chemical identities currently claimed as CBI and not available on the TSCA Inventory or in publically-available health studies submitted to the Agency. In addition, EPA challenged industry to reduce the number of CBI claims in new TSCA filings.
Support Information for Confidentiality Claims
Information submitted under specific reporting requirements of TSCA, or in support of TSCA, is subject to the provisions of Section 14 of TSCA and to EPA's Regulations on the Confidentiality of Business Information (see 40 CFR Part 2). Failure to follow these procedures fully at the time of document submission to EPA will be interpreted by the Agency as a waiver of confidentiality claims.
Asserting a Claim
Information claimed as confidential should be clearly marked by bracketing, circling, or underlining. All pages containing such information should also be stamped "CONFIDENTIAL." Care should be taken to ensure that these markings do not obscure the submission's text.
To assert a claim of confidentiality, the submitter must submit two versions of any documents containing information claimed as confidential. One copy should be complete, with the information being claimed as confidential marked in the manner described above. The other copy should have all of the information claimed as confidentia either removed or completely obscured. This sanitized version will be placed in EPA's Public Files. More information is available in Part X. of the March 16, 1978, Federal Register notice (43 FR 1113).
Substantiating claims of Confidentiality
Detailed written responses to the following questions should be provided to substantiate confidentiality claim(s). Responses should be as specific as possible, with examples as appropriate, and should provide substantiation arguments for all types of information (e.g., sales, or production/ importation volumes, chemical identity, company identity) claimed as confidential.
- Is your company asserting this confidential business information (CBI) claim on its own behalf? If the answer is no, please provide company name, address and telephone number of entity asserting claim.
- For what period do you assert your claim(s) of confidentiality? If the claim is to extend until a certain event or point in time, please indicate that event or time period. Explain why such information should remain confidential until such point.
- Has the information that you are claiming as confidential been disclosed to any other governmental agency, or to this Agency at any other time? Identify the Agency to which the information was disclosed and provide the date and circumstances of the same. Was the disclosure accompanied by a claim of confidentiality? If yes, attach a copy of said document reflecting the confidentiality agreement.
- Briefly describe any physical or procedural restrictions within your company relating to the use and storage of the information you are claiming CBI.
- If anyone outside your company has access to any of the information claimed CBI, are they restricted by confidentiality agreement(s). If so, explain the content of the agreement(s).
- Does the information claimed as confidential appear or is it referred
to in any of the following:
a. Advertising or promotional material for the chemical substance or the resulting and product;
b. Material safety data sheets or other similar materials (such as technical data sheets) for the substance or resulting end product (include copies of this information as it appears when accompanying the substance and/or product at the time of transfer or sale);
c. Professional or trade publications; or
d. Any other media or publications available to the public or to your competitors.
If you answered yes to any of the above, indicate where the information appears, include copies, and explain why it should nonetheless be treated as confidential.
- Has EPA, another federal agency, or court made any confidentiality determination regarding information associated with this substance? If so, provide copies of such determinations.
- Describe the substantial harmful effects that would result to your competitive position if the CBI information is made available to the public? In your answer, explain the causal relationship between disclosure and any resulting substantial harmful effects. Consider in your answer such constraints as capital and marketing cost, specialized technical expertise, or unusual processes and your competitors access to your customers. Address each piece of information claimed CBI separately.
- Has the substance been patented in the U.S. or elsewhere? Is a patent for the substance currently pending?
- Is this substance/product commercially available and if so, for how long
has it been available on the commercial market?
a. a. If on the commercial market, are your competitors aware that the substance is commercially available in the U.S.?
b. b. If not already commercially available, describe what stage of research and development (R&D) the substance is in, and estimate bow soon a market will be established.
c. c. What is the substance used for and what type of product(s) does it appear in.
- Describe whether a competitor could employ reverse engineering to identically recreate the substance?
- Do you assert that disclosure of this information you are claiming CBI
a. a. confidential processes used in manufacturing the substance;
b. b. if a mixture, the actual portions of the substance in the mixture; or
c. c. information unrelated to the effects of the substance on human health or the environment?
If your answer to any of the above questions is yes, explain how such information would be revealed.
- Provide the Chemical Abstract Service Registry Number for the product, if known. Is your company applying for a CAS number now or in the near future? If you have applied for a CAS number, include a copy of the contract with CAS.
- Is the substance or any information claimed CBI the subject of FIFRA
regulation or reporting? If so, explain.