WPC5 2 BPZ Courier 12cpi#|xAd6X@8;@HP LaserJet 3SIHP3SI.PRSd6X@8;,\,K@2 <@#P ZsPE|D#|xCourierCG Times BoldCourier BoldHP LaserJet 5LHPLAS5L.PRS5x  @\\j"eaX@2W X  av&?xxx,Q#x6X@`7X@.7zC;,*Xz_ pi7X?xxx,Yx `7X.&&6&K=t Š&6*ȋ&&5&&*2+&"4|Jx ^;C]ddCCCdCCCCddddddddddCCdxN`xoCCCddCdoYoYFdo8Co8odooYNCodddYdddddddddCddddddddo8dddddYYYYYN8N8N8N8oddddooooddpddddxodddXXYYXYYXddddddoL8N8N8N8p`o8P8N8ppoddXXYpLoNpLoNPDopoopodXYXo8oYoNCdddoCddCCCWxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxNdddCdUUddddddFddddFCCssd44ddxxddd~ooCsdF"dsddCCxCddoddCdYds`xUvdddCCCCxoxoYNYYYN8YooYdYxxdxddYYxoxxxxNY88YYYxYxxxxCCdddddddxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxNNNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY888888888888YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxCxNxdYC\   pxtll\tll@\@\`La8DocumentgDocument Style StyleXX` `  ` 2tpkkda4DocumentgDocument Style Style . a6DocumentgDocument Style Style GX  a5DocumentgDocument Style Style }X(# a2DocumentgDocument Style Style<o   ?  A.  2vt *a7DocumentgDocument Style StyleyXX` ` (#` BibliogrphyBibliography:X (# a1Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbers:`S@ I.  X(# a2Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbers C @` A. ` ` (#` 2   R a3DocumentgDocument Style Style B b  ?  1.  a3Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbers L! ` ` @P 1. ` `  (# a4Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbers Uj` `  @ a. ` (# a5Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbers _o` `  @h(1)  hh#(#h 25ia6Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph Numbersh` `  hh#@$(a) hh#((# a7Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph NumberspfJ` `  hh#(@*i) (h-(# a8Right ParRight-Aligned Paragraph NumbersyW"3!` `  hh#(-@p/a) -pp2(#p a1DocumentgDocument Style StyleXqq   l ^) I. ׃  2+gDoc InitInitialize Document Style  0*0*  I. A. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a) I. 1. A. a.(1)(a) i) a)DocumentgTech InitInitialize Technical Style. k I. A. 1. a.(1)(a) i) a) 1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 .1 Technicala5TechnicalTechnical Document Style)WD (1) . a6TechnicalTechnical Document Style)D (a) . 2 'a2TechnicalTechnical Document Style<6  ?  A.   a3TechnicalTechnical Document Style9Wg  2  1.   a4TechnicalTechnical Document Style8bv{ 2  a.   a1TechnicalTechnical Document StyleF!<  ?  I.   2(& G!!X%a7TechnicalTechnical Document Style(@D i) . a8TechnicalTechnical Document Style(D a) . PleadingHeader for numbered pleading paperP@n   $] X X` hp x (#%'0*,.8135@8:P +%"MAJOR NAAQS IMPLEMENTATION MILESTONES P  12/96 r 3/97 K 6/97 $ 9/97  12/97  3/98 ! 6/98 & 9/98 a+ 12/98 :0 3/99 5 6/99   v v  M M ' '     ! ! & & e+ e+ >0 >0 5 5M w =6   Proposals: %KIIP, PM Monitoring,   O3/PM NAAQS.  Publish ANPR. *(12/96)  UFinal Action: 3KIIP, PM Monitoring,   O3/PM NAAQS. `Propose Phase I, Ozone Monitoring. *(7/97) SC ^Mtg T(2/97) P SC  Mtg 3 h(4/97)   SC NMtg o(6/97)  SC )Mtg o(8/97)  SC Mtg o(10/97) &Phase I K!_Final Action (2/98). {#TPropose Phase II. !,&O3 Monitoring Final Action.  >(7/98) h3Phase II  48Final Action. 2(7/99)  )Prelim Ph I  Rpt to CAAAC. _&IIP Principles  to CAAAC. )Phase I  qRpt to CAAAC.  B(4/97)  )Prelim Ph II  Rpt to CAAAC. B(12/97)  !)Final Ph II  "Rpt to CAAAC. | B(3/98) hh h        k  j  A k y z  ( ILk& &cU  7U   . #  k  lHq >P  $ATTACHMENT A1    7  F d P b(12/96) 3a5555 re+n .L !"#-#u"9*( ---DDD[[[rrr P  /#Conceptual / Model PP 5//&GENERAL AQ MANAGEMENT AND ISSUE PAPER FLOWCHART  Z(ATTACHMENT A2 P !i"Define Authority, Boundary, i Participants and Locations  iEstablish  J, Convene Reg'l  J,Planning Area iPlanning Areas  !,Determine AOI  hDetermine AOV  I0Identify I0Control I0PRegions 0Control 0Strategy ('~Develop (''Cost ('Data !@Classify !Areas $Initiate Modeling  Analyze  bMonitoring  Data JUse J+Existing  JMet/Model/  J|Monitor Data JMSelect JEpisodes g MReview  g Meteorology -j Select -Modeling  -Centers and -Domains JDevelop Emiss. Inv., Jadd PM-fine and PM- Jfine Precursors, J Tracking Capability, J and Attainment Areasi&QY0*(U)  A Az$V OCH!O/ + = =RK o+R (g W |  BA  E$r)ro+r)) 1Q11%1E1 2223V2 3 3 3" 3 13  [-.Y0.y. :(g*+g*Wg* $$t$W$t%t x x xO   s     V   g  7 | K g gg    pQpp QO ootottO\./\.e\.  / /#//## ###T j jj jO    3'3'Standard'3'3StandardHPLAS5L.PRS5x  PE #Xz_ pi7*X#y!1h)wx:&ddATTA1.CGM<<y$.... !.$0 xxx. !0 '3'3StandardHPLAS5L.PRS5x  '3'3StandardrJet 5L.>APE yAh)x9*ddATTA2.CGM3%y$....A.$0xxx.'#A0  ? #x6X@`7Q#X@# '3'3StandardrJet 5L.>A3'3'Standardigned Paragraph Numbers|D   @A-3-@  Z M!ATTACHMENT A3 ISSUE PAPER PRINCIPLES AND DEVELOPMENT PROCESSZIssue papers need to be developed in a consistent manner, based upon the same underlying principles. Included below are the process and contentrelated principles that need to be applied to these papers and the process that should be followed for the actual development of the papers. A. ProcessRelated Principles for Issue Paper Development  ?  1.` ` Active participation is needed by all members in the work group. (EPA will take appropriate steps to assure that all work group members have an opportunity to provide input on issues prior to discussion at work group or Subcommittee meetings.(#`  ?  2.` ` Work groups need to continue striving for consensus recommendations. consensus is defined as support for a position by a majority of members from all groups of affected interests (i.e. States, industry, public interest). Consensus does not require unanimous support of all members from affected groups.(#`  ?0  3.` ` If the work group cannot reach consensus on a recommendation, then the work group positions with the most support should be presented as options. Viewpoints with less support must be put in writing with a detailed rationale by the supporters of the viewpoint. When a work group sector disagrees with a position, the matter may be referred to a smaller ad hoc group for resolution.(#`  ?8  4.` ` Issue papers and presentations to the Subcommittee must fully describe the positions of all work group members and, to the greatest extent possible, set forth the work group's recommendations. Presentations of the work group issue papers to the Subcommittee should emphasize recommendations/options and the rationale underlying viewpoints with less than full work group support.(#`  ?@ 5.` ` Latest drafts of issue papers and other materials to be presented to the subcommittee must be on the TTN 7 days prior to the subcommittee meeting. (Onepage summaries of issue papers may be acceptable substitutes for the full paper where no recommendations/options are being presented.)(#`  ?$  6.` ` The Coordination Group will, in consultation with EPA, develop appropriate principles regarding content of issue papers for the guidance of the work groups.(#` H&0*''@@Ԍ B. ContentRelated Principles for Issue Paper Development Issue papers being developed for Subcommittee consideration should be based upon the following principles:  ?  1.` ` Progress toward attainment of revised NAAQS and achievement of regional haze program requirements should be achieved in an expeditious manner. Timetables for achieving progress should be informed by consideration of a number of factors, including health and environmental benefits, cost and technical impediments, available scientific information, requirements of the CAA, and administrative requirements.(#`  ?  2.` ` In the event of State or other responsible institutions failure to plan (or to participate in planning) and implement plans, within the designated time frames, the Federal government must take timely action to remedy the situation.(#`  ?h  3.` ` All options/recommendations must be based upon specified deadlines for planning, implementing and attaining the NAAQS and implementing regional haze program requirements.(#`  ?P  4.` ` All options/recommendations which may require amendments to the CAA must be clearly identified with advantages and disadvantages for such changes analyzed.(#`  ?p  5.` ` Assure timely environmental progress. Timely environmental progress means, at a minimum, continuing air quality improvements at a rate no less rapid than will be required to meet the current NAAQS. Early Federal, State and local actions to improve PM fine air quality should be encouraged.(#`  ?  6.` ` Control strategies should be effective in achieving air quality objectives, should be designed to accommodate flexible response methods by emission sources, and should encourage continuing improvements in air quality. To this end, the advantages, disadvantages, and available information on cost effectiveness of a full range of control methods should be presented, including technologybased performance standards, marketbased approaches, and other traditional and nontraditional approaches.(#`  ?%  7.` ` All options/recommendations should provide for the use of best available, scientificallybased explanations toH&0*''@@ be used in planning requirements and control strategy development. Such options/recommendations should include methods to identify the role of nonlocal transport processes and mechanisms designed to address such processes.(#`  ?  8.` ` Opportunities for integration of planning and implementation for ozone, PM and haze that achieve better environmental results and lower costs should be fully pursued. (#`  ?  9.` ` Planning and implementation proposals should identify methods for early and continued involvement of potentially affected interests, to the maximum extent possible, to assist in the attainment of the revised NAAQS and achieving reasonable progress toward regional haze program goals.(#` C. Issue Paper Development Process Issue papers being prepared for Subcommittee consideration should be developed as follows:  ?  1.` ` EPA takes the responsibility to prepare the background portion of the issue paper. Within EPA, this is accomplished by assigning staff (OAQPS, OMS, OAP) and OGC to work with a contractor to draft the background. This would describe the issue and pose salient questions which EPA believes the paper needs to address e.g., connection to AOI or AOV concept or how the options or approaches in this paper affect other papers.(#`  ?  2.` ` External lead/leads review the background and salient questions and lead work group discussion to brainstorm the options/principles which would form the basis of the paper. This could include review of the key issues/salient questions the paper must address. The results of this would be condensed to a set of principles/options for a preliminary presentation to the Coordination Group and the Subcommittee.(#`  ?  3.` ` The background, salient questions and principles/options are posted on the TTN bulletin board for review and comment.(#`  ?#  4.` ` Background, salient questions and principles/options are presented to the Coordination Group and the Subcommittee for their consideration. Based upon these discussions, modifications could be made to the productH&0*''@@ of the work group. Coordination Group review could focus on comprehensiveness and balance. The Subcommittee could take this early opportunity to review the principles and salient questions and provide feedback/direction to the work group before the details of the paper are drafted.(#`  ?x  5.` ` Based upon work group, Coordination Group, and Subcommittee discussions and any written comments received by the external lead, the contractor will draft a detailed issue paper. For the purpose of providing direction to the contractor, the external lead will coordinate with the EPA staff lead to provide the EPA Work Assignment Manager with the necessary information to provide technical direction to the contractor.(#`  ?H  6.` ` The work group considers the drafted paper with a goal of making a recommendation(s).(#`  ?  7.` ` The contractor prepares a plain English summary of the issue paper prior to Coordination Group/Subcommittee discussion. This summary is also provided to the Communications and Outreach work group for their review.(#`  ?P  8.` ` Coordination Group/Subcommittee is presented with the fully drafted paper and recommendation for their consideration. This presentation should outline the options/principles which formed the basis of the paper. The purpose of the discussion is to focus the Subcommittee on the recommendation(s)/principles to see if they need to be changed, reconsidered or endorsed. (#`  ?  9.` ` The contractor revises the plain English summary based on the Subcommittee discussion. This final summary is provided to the Communications and Outreach work group for dissemination.(#`  ?x 10.` ` Final issue papers are posted to the TTN.(#` x0*''@@ 3'3'Standardigned Paragraph Numbers3'3'Standardl Document Style|D    @A-3-A-4-@  ATTACHMENT A4 STAFFING SUMMARY AD HOC GROUPS AND CAUCUSES   Several ad hoc groups and caucuses have been formed in order to address specific ozone, PM and regional haze implementation strategy issues. The ad hoc groups are composed of representatives from a wide range of sectors affected by the implementation strategy. The ad hoc groups were formed in order to focus specifically on certain issues that are not appropriate for the Coordination Group and the Subcommittee to consider in detail. The caucuses are composed of representatives from a single affected sector and consider implementation issues of a wider nature than do the ad hoc groups. The purpose of the caucuses is to provide a forum for these sectors to raise issues outside of the more formal Coordination Group and Subcommittee structure. Listed on the following pages are the names of the ad hoc groups and caucuses as well as other pertinent information about their composition. The work of the caucuses is coordinated by the Coordination Group and their recommendations, issues and concerns are communicated to the full Subcommittee through the Coordination Group. The work of the Prescribed Burning Ad Hoc Group is also coordinated by the Coordination Group. The work of the Monitoring Ad Hoc Group is coordinated by the Base Programs and Analyses Work Group.0*(( 3'3'Standardl Document Style'3'3Standardl Document StylePE  HH  ^ ddx !ddx&FVo  ^  ATTACHMENT A4 STAFFING SUMMARY AD HOC GROUPS AND CAUCUSES   GROUP  CHAIRPERSON(S) EPA PRIMARY STAFF PERSON  SUBCOMMITTEE MEMBERS  Environmental Caucus Shaver+ Beal+ David Baron+ AZ Center for Law in the Public Interest  3 3 Thomas Godar (Ron White)  American Lung Assoc.@ ; ; ; David Hawkins; NRDC@@  { { { Bruce Hill{ Appalachian Mtn. Club@@;     Bob Palzer Sierra Club@@{     Robert Russell Conservation Law Foundation@@  ; ; ; Chris Shaver; EDF@ Federal Agency CaucusS HamiltonS GerthS Abraham Haspel (Jean Vernet)S DOE@;    George Bluhm Dept of Agriculture@S    Elsie Munsell (Alison Ling) DOD (Navy)@    Molly Ross DOI@    Mike Dombeck (Donna Lamb) Forest Service@ # # # Jim Shrouds# DOT@P Legal Caucuss Pat Rahers Dunkinss Larry Feldcamps Baker & BottsP@#    David Hawkins NRDC@@s    Alison Ling DOD (Navy)@@ 3 3 3 Tim O'Brien3 FordkH!HH@@ @ @ @ Pat Raher@ Hogan & Hartson@@    Lydia Wegman (7) OAR/OAQPS@@@    Bob Wyman Latham & Watkins@ Monitoring Incentives Ad Hoc Group Gerald, Wayland Gerald, Wayland Diana Andrews (4) State of Kentucky@    Richard Dworek U. S. Steel@@   X X Rich Halvey (3)X Western Governors Assoc.@@    Beverly Hartsock State of Texas@@X    Bruce Hill Appalachian Mtn. Club@@     Shawn Kendall Phelps Dodge@@  X X X Marvin Lowrey (2)X State of Georgia@@     Bob Palzer Sierra Club@pX  Prescribed Burning Ad Hoc Group Shaver Woodard Bill Becker STAPPA/ALAPCOp x x x William Dickerson (7) Office of Federal Activities@ P P P James Douglas (8)P DOI@@    Anita Frankel (7) Region X@@P    James Hubbard (8) Colorado State Forest Service@@    Mary Jo Lavin (8) USDA Forest Service@@ P P P Donna Lamb (2)P USDA Forest Service@@    Brian Mitchell (8) National Park Service H!3 3 @@P @ @ @ Bob Palzer@ Sierra Club@@    Howard Rhodes (8) Florida Dept. of Env. Protection@@    Les Rosenkrance (6) Nat'l Interagency Fire Center@    Sandra Silva (8) U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service@@    Ron Tickle (8) US Navy@@ H H H Arch Wells (8)H Bureau of Indian Affairs@@    Joe Williams State of Washington@H Small Entities Caucus} Hamilton Elmore Russell Batson American Furniture Manufacturers Assoc.@     Kevin Bromberg SBA@       Nicholas Bush (Bruce Craig) Natural Gas Supply Assoc.@  ( ( ( Ben Cooper( Printing Industries of America@ h h h Dmitri (Jim) Daskal0 Natl Coalition of Petroleum Retailers & Gasoline Auto Service Dealers@( 8 8 8 David D'Onofrio8 Natl Small Business United@ x x x Susan Eckerlyx Natl Federation of Independent Businesses8    Sherry Edwards Synthetic Organic Chemical Manufacturers Assoc@@    Douglas Greenhaus Natl Auto Dealers Assoc H!3 3 @@H @ @ @ Carter Keithley@ Hearth Products Assoc.@@    Paul Kerkhoven American Highway Users Alliance@@    Jeff Leiter (Chet Thompson) SIGMA/NACS/ILMA/OPEI    Mark Morgan Petroleum Transport and Storage Assoc    Christian Richter (Bill Sonntag) NAMF/AESF/MFSA    John Satagaj Small Business Legislative Council    Mary Scalco International Fabricare Institute@     Allen Schaeffer American Trucking Association@  ( ( ( Jeb Stuart( Construction Industries Air Quality Coalition  0 0 0 Matthew Ward (Ken Brown) Natl Assoc of Local Govt Environmental Professionals@ 8 8 8 Bill Wemhoff8 American Public Power Assoc.@P Western Issues CaucusD Ginsburg Blais Nina Dougherty (2) Sierra ClubP@8    Rich Halvey (3) Western Governors Assoc@@    Dan Johnson (2) State of Washington@@ H H H Donna Lamb (2)H Forest Service@@    John Leary (2) Western Governors Assoc H!3 3 @@H @ @ @ Mark Scruggs (4)@ DOI@@    Chris Shaver EDF@@@    Quin Shea (5) Natl Mining Assoc@@    Eric Skelton (3) Spokane County@@ @ @ @ Scott Thomas (5)@ State of Oklahoma@@    Jean Vernet (3) DOE@K@ Y !ddx&FVo  AddxH   Y @@@ 1. Membership may be expanded in future.@@H 2. Not on Subcommittee Nat'l/Regional Strategies WG member@@  3. Not on Subcommittee Base Programs WG member@@  4.H Not on Subcommittee Science/Technology WG member@@  5. Not on Subcommittee Communications/Outreach WG member@@H  6. Membership not yet determined.@@ 7. EPA@@ 8.H Not on subcommittee or work group.@H H!3 3   ?  '3'3Standardl Document Style3'3'StandardrJet 5L.>A|DHH #x6X@`7Q#X@#  @A-4-page A-5-@  H3DATTACHMENT A5 SUBCOMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LISTH` `  hh#(-pp27  < April 1, 1997 *  Subcommittee for the Development of Ozone, Particulate Matter P and Regional Haze Implementation Programs < (Membership Listing)  ?@  CoChair Mr. John Seitz, Director Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (MD10) Research Triangle Park, NC 27711  ? Phone: (919) 5415616 hh#Fax: (919) 5412464  ?  CoChair Dr. Alan Krupnick Senior Fellow Resources for the Future 1616 P Street N.W. Washington, DC 20036  ? Phone: (202) 3285107hh#Fax: (202) 9393460  ?  Designated Federal Officer  Mr. William Hamilton Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (MD12) U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Research Triangle Park, NC 27711  ?8 Phone: (919) 54l5498hh#Fax: (919) 54l2664  ?   STATE, LOCAL AND TRIBAL REPRESENTATIVES ă Mr. Victor Ashe Mayor, City of Knoxville P. O. Box 1631 Knoxville, TN 37901  ?@ Phone: (423) 2152040hh#Fax: (423) 2152978@ -)) Mr. S. William Becker* Executive Director State and Territorial Air Pollution Program Administrators/ Association of Local Air Pollution Control Officials 444 North Capitol Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20001  ? Phone: (202) 6247864hh#Fax: (202) 6247863 Ms. Carla Berroyer American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) Illinois Department of Transportation 2300 South Dirksen Parkway Springfield, IL 62764  ? Phone: (217) 7827868hh#Fax: (217) 7850468 Mr. John D. Dunlap, III* Chairman, California Air Resources Board 2020 L Street, 5th Floor Sacramento, CA 95814  ? Phone: (916) 3225840hh#Fax: (916) 3275748 Ms. Mary Gade,* Director Illinois Environmental Protection Agency 2200 Churchill Road Springfield, IL 627949276  ?P Phone: (217) 7823397hh#Fax: (217) 7829039 Mr. Stephen L. Gerritson* Executive Director Lake Michigan Air Director's Consortium 2350 East Devon Avenue, Suite 242 Des Plaines, IL 60018  ? Phone: (847) 2962181hh#Fax: (847) 2962958 Ms. Beverly Hartsock* Deputy Executive Director Texas Natural Resources Conservation Commission P.O. Box 13087 Austin, TX 787113087  ?@ Phone: (512) 2395818hh#Fax: (512) 2394808 or 2390676@-)) Dr. James M. Lents Executive Officer South Coast Air Resources Board 21865 East Copley Drive Diamond Bar, CA 91765  ? Phone: (909) 3962100hh#Fax: (909) 3963340 Mr. Tom Looby Director of the Office of Environment Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment 4300 Cherry Creek Drive South Denver, CO 802221530  ?` Phone: (303) 6923099hh#Fax: (303) 7824969 Mr. Langdon Marsh, Director Oregon Department of Environmental Quality 811 SW 6th Avenue Portland, OR 972041390  ? Phone: (503) 2295696hh#Fax:((503) 2295850 Mr. Jerry Pardilla, Director National Tribal Environmental Council 2221 Rio Grande, N.W. Albuquerque, NM 87104  ? Phone: (505) 2422175hh#Fax:((505) 2422654 Mr. John Poorman Staff Director Capital District Transportation Committee 5 Computer Drive West Albany, NY 12205  ?8 Phone: (518) 4582161hh#Fax: (518) 4592155 Mr. Harold Reheis, Director Environmental Protection Division Georgia Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street, SE, Suite 1152 Atlanta, GA 30334  ? Phone: (404) 6564713hh#Fax: (404) 6515778-)) Ms. Susan Savage Mayor, City of Tulsa 200 Civic Center Tulsa, Oklahoma 74103  ?  Phone: (918) 5967411hh#Fax: (918) 5969010 Mr. Robert Shinn Commissioner Office of the Commissioner New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection 401 East State Street CN 402 Trenton, NJ 08625  ?` Phone: (609) 2922885hh#Fax:((609) 2927695 Mr. James M. Souby Executive Director Western Governors' Association 60017th Street Suite 1705 South Tower Denver, CO 802025452  ? Phone: (303) 6239378 hh#Fax: (303) 5347309 Ms. Betty Lou Ward Wake County Commissioner P.O. Box 550 Raleigh, NC 27602  ?P Phone: (919) 8566160hh#Fax: (919) 8565699 Mr. Joe Williams, President WESTAR P.O. Box 47600 Olympia, Washington 985047600  ? Phone: (360) 4076879 hh#Fax: (360) 4076802-))  ?   PUBLIC INTEREST AND ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS ă Mr. David Baron Assistant Director Arizona Center for Law in the Public Interest 1840 E. River Road, Suite 207 Tucson, AZ 857185892  ?x Phone: (520) 5291798hh#Fax: (520) 5292927 Mr. Stephen G. Brick Clean Air Task Force 5714 Tolman Terrace Madison, WI 537113443  ?( Phone: (608) 2775711hh#Fax: (608) 2775564 Mr. Hank Dittmar Executive Director Surface Transportation Policy Project 140016th Street, N.W., Suite 300 Washington, D.C. 20036  ? Phone: (202) 4662636hh#Fax: (202) 4662247 Dr. Thomas J. Godar,* M.D. American Lung Association 114 Woodland Street Hartford, CT 06105  ?P Phone: (860) 7144055hh#Fax: (860) 7148035 Mr. David Hawkins,* Esq Senior Attorney Natural Resources Defense Council 1200 New York Avenue N.W., Suite 400 Washington, D.C. 20005  ? Phone: (202) 2896868 hh#Fax: (202) 2891060 Dr. L. Bruce Hill Staff Scientist Research Department Appalachian Mountain Club Route 16, Pinkham Notch Jackson, NH 03846 (Federal Express address only) P.O. Box 298 (USPS or UPS address) Route 16, Pinkham Notch Gorham, NH 03581  ?`" Phone: (603) 4662721 Ext. 111-Fax: (603) 4662822`"-)) Mr. G. Alex Johnson, Director Citizens Commission for Clean Air in the Lake Michigan Basin 152 West Wisconsin Avenue Milwaukee, WI 532032508  ? Phone: (414) 2717467hh#Fax: (414) 2717312 Mr. William V. Luneburg Group Against Smog and Pollution 3900 Forbes Avenue Pittsburgh, PA 15260  ? Phone: (412) 6481380hh#Fax: (412) 6482649 Mr. David Marshall, Staff Attorney Conservation Law Foundation One Eagle Square, Suite 1A Concord, New Hampshire 03301  ?H Phone: (603) 2253060 hh#Fax: (603) 2253059 Mr. Joe Minott Executive Director Clean Air Council 135 S. 19th Street, Suite 300 Philadelphia, PA 19103  ? Phone: (215) 5674004 Ext. 223-Fax: (215) 5675791 Dr. Robert Palzer Sierra Club 1610 NW 118th Court Portland, OR 97229  ?p Phone: (503) 5208671hh#Fax: (503) 5200677 Ms. Christine Shaver Senior Attorney Environmental Defense Fund 1405 Arapahoe Avenue Boulder, CO 80302  ? Phone: (303) 4404901 hh#Fax: (303) 4408052  ?@  INDUSTRY/TRADE GROUPS ă Mr. Vincent J. Brisini,* Environment Manager Pennsylvania Electric Company 1001 Broad Street Johnstown, PA 15907  ?# Phone: (814) 5338811hh#Fax: (814) 5338085#-)) Mr. Nicholas Bush Natural Gas Supply Association 80515th Street, N.W., Suite 510 Washington, D.C. 20005  ?  Phone: (202) 3269300 hh#Fax: (202) 3269330 Ms. Georgia Callahan, Manager Legislative and Regulatory Affairs Texaco P. O. Box 509 Beacon, NY 12508  ? Phone: (914) 8387645hh#Fax:((914) 8387115 Mr. Lawrence Codey* President & Chief Operating Officer Public Service Electric & Gas Company 80 Park Plaza, 4th Floor Newark, NJ 07101  ? Phone: (201) 4305670 hh#Fax: (201) 6433367 Mr. Ben Cooper,* Senior Vice President for Governmental Affairs Printing Industries of America 100 Daingerfield Road Alexandria, VA 22314  ? Phone: (703) 5198115hh#Fax: (703) 5483227 Mr. Richard Dworek, General Manager Environmental Affairs and Air Management U.S. Steel 600 Grant Street Pittsburgh, PA 15219  ? Phone: (412) 4335910hh#Fax: (412) 4335920 Mr. Jeff Gabriel, Director Environmental Services and Policy Education National Pork Producers Council 1776 N.W. 114th Street Clive, IA 50325  ?x Phone: (515) 2232633hh#Fax: (515) 2232646 Dr. Charles H. Goodman,* Vice President Research and Environmental Affairs Southern Company Services, Inc. 14N8195, P.O. Box 2625 Birmingham, AL 35202  ?# Phone (205) 2576325 hh#Fax:((205) 2577938#-)) Mr. Stan Hathcock Webster South Inc 683 Highland Avenue Atlanta, GA 30312  ?  Phone: (404) 5228227hh#Fax: (404) 6581660 Mr. Richard M. Hayslip, Manager Environment, Land, and Risk Management Salt River Project P.O. Box 52025 Phoenix, AZ 850722025  ? Phone: (602) 2366699hh#Fax: (602) 2363407 Mr. Ben G. Henneke* President, Clean Air Corporation 36 S. Charles Street, Suite 190 Baltimore, MD 21201  ?H Phone: (410) 5762200hh#Fax: (410) 5767975 Mr. Mike Hertel Southern California Edison 2244 Walnut Grove Avenue Rosemead, CA 91770  ? Phone: (818) 3029456 hh#Fax: (818) 3029730 Mr. Carter Keithley, President Hearth Products Association 1601 N Kent Street Suite 1001 Arlington, VA 22209  ?p Phone: (703) 5220086hh#Fax:((703) 5220548 Mr. Shawn Kendall Phelps Dodge Corporation 2600 N Central Avenue Phoenix, AZ 850043014  ?  Phone: (602) 2348308hh#Fax:((602) 2344814 Mr. Paul Kerkhoven Manager of Environmental Affairs American Highway Users Alliance 1776 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W., Suite 500 Washington, D.C. 20036  ?! Phone: (202) 8571231hh#Fax: (202) 8571220 Mr. Jed Mandel Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg 2 North LaSalle Street, Suite 2200 Chicago, IL 60602  ?H& Phone: (312) 2691747hh#Fax: (312) 2698042H&-)) Mr. Timothy J. OBrien, Director Environmental Quality Office Ford Motor Company One Parklane Boulevard, Suite 1400 Dearborn, Michigan 481262477  ? Phone: (313) 3232895hh#Fax: (313) 3225904 Ms. Sarah PeirceSandner Eastman Kodak Company 1100 Ridgway Avenue, Building 320 Rochester, NY 146526263  ? Phone: (716) 5886477 hh#Fax: (716) 7223695 Mr. Richard Phelps Eastman Chemical Company Eastman Road P. O. Box 1993 Kingsport, TN 376625393  ? Phone: (423) 2295164hh#Fax: (423) 2294864 Mr. John Satagaj, President Small Business Legislative Council 115615th Street, N.W., Suite 510 Washington, D.C. 20005  ? Phone: (202) 6398500hh#Fax: (202) 2965333 Mr. Allen Schaeffer Vice President for Environmental Affairs American Trucking Association 2200 Mill Road Alexandria, VA 22314  ?8 Phone: (703) 8381844hh#Fax: (703) 8381992 Mr. Karl R. Schultz E.I. Dupont De Nemours & Company Brandywine Building (B5226) Wilmington, DE 19898  ? Phone: (302) 7734394 hh#Fax: (302) 7734494 Mr. William Shapiro,* Manager Regulatory Compliance and Environmental Affairs Volvo Cars of North America Volvo Drive Rockleigh, NJ 076470913  ?`" Phone: (201) 7674772hh#Fax: (201) 7844525`"-)) Mr. F. Bradford Smith Chairman of the Board of Directors Environmental Elements Corporation P. O. Box 1318 3700 Koppers Street Baltimore, MD 21227  ? Phone: (410) 3687090 (Fax: (410) 3686721 Mr. Paul C. Smith Policy Consulting Services 7617 Lynn Drive Chevy Chase, MD 20815  ?` Phone: (202) 6753380hh#Fax: (202) 6754230 Ms. Susan R. Stark Manager, Environmental Health and Safety ARCO Products Company 1990 W. Crescent Avenue Anaheim, CA 92801  ? Phone: (714) 4916844hh#Fax: (714) 4916942 Mr. Jeb Stuart Vice President for Technical Matters Construction Industry Air Quality Coalition 1330 S. Valley Vista Drive Diamond Bar, CA 91765  ?P Phone: (714) 6407760hh#Fax: (714) 6407725 Mr. John Taunton Exxon Company, USA Box 2180 Houston, TX 77252  ? Phone: (713) 6562401 hh#Fax: (713) 6566594 Mr. Chet Thompson, Associate Collier, Shannon, Rill and Scott 3050 K Street, N.W., Suite 400 Washington, D.C. 20007  ? Phone: (202) 3428815hh#Fax: (202) 3428451 Mr. Ted Wernick, Director Scientific Regulatory Affairs The Gillette Company 401 Professional Drive Gaithersburg, MD 20879  ?(# Phone: (301) 5901543 (Fax: (301) 5901535(#-))  ? < UNION REPRESENTATION ă Mr. Mike Wright Health, Safety and Environmental Department of the United Steelworkers of America 5 Gateway Center Pittsburgh, PA 15222  ?x Phone: (412) 5622580hh#Fax: (412) 5622584  ? x! LAWYERS/CONSULTANTS ă Mr. Richard E. Ayres* Howrey & Simon 1299 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20004  ? Phone: (202) 3836778hh#Fax: (202) 3836610 Mr. Larry Feldcamp,* Esq Partner Baker & Botts 3000 One Shell Plaza Houston, TX 77002  ? Phone: (713) 2291573hh#Fax: (713) 2291522 Mr. William H. Lewis,* Esq Counsel to Clean Air Implementation Project Morgan, Lewis & Bockius 1800 M. Street N.W. Washington, D. C. 20036  ?8 Phone: (202) 4677000hh#Fax: (202) 4677176 Mr. Patrick Raher,* Esq Hogan & Hartson 555 13th Street N.W. Washington, D.C. 20004  ? Phone: (202) 6375682hh#Fax: (202) 6375910 Mr. Robert A. Wyman,* Partner Latham & Watkins 633 West 5th Street Los Angeles, CA 90071  ?! Phone: (213) 4851234 hh#Fax: (213) 8918763!-))  ? x! SCIENTIFIC/ACADEMIA ă Dr. Glen R. Cass Environmental Engineering California Institute of Technology 13878 Pasadena, CA 91125  ?x Phone: (818) 3956888 hh#Fax: (818) 3952940 Dr. Jane Hall California State UniversityFullerton Department of Economics Fullerton, CA 92634  ?( Phone: (714) 7732236 hh#Fax: (714) 7733097 Dr. Harvey Jeffries Department of Environmental Science and Engineering School of Public Health, 201H University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, NC 27514  ? Phone: (919) 9423245hh#Fax:((919) 9670160 Dr. Armistead Russell School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Daniel Lab Georgia Tech 200 Bobby Dodd Way Atlanta, GA 30332  ? Phone: (404) 8943079hh#Fax:((404) 8949724  ?8 ," FEDERAL AGENCIES ă Mr. George Bluhm Natural Resource Conservation Service Department of Agriculture University of California 151 Hoagland Hall Davis, CA 956168627  ?x Phone: (916) 7521018hh#Fax:((916) 7521552 Mr. Mike Dombeck, Chief Forest Service Department of Agriculture 201 14th Street, SW Washington, DC 20250  ?# Phone: (202) 2051661hh#Fax:((202) 2051765#-)) Dr. Abraham Haspel Acting Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for Policy Department of Energy 7C016 Forrestal Building PO1 1000 Independence Avenue, SW Washington, DC 20585  ? Phone: (202) 5865316 hh#Fax: (202) 5863047 Mr. David Howekamp Director, Air Division Environmental Protection Agency, Region IX 75 Hawthorne Street San Francisco, CA 94105  ?( Phone: (415) 7441219hh#Fax: (415) 7441077 Mr. Thomas Maslany, Director Air, Radiation and Toxics Division Environmental Protection Agency, Region III 841 Chestnut Building Philadelphia, PA 19107  ? Phone: (215) 5662100hh#Fax: (215) 5662101 Ms. Elsie Munsell* Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Navy (Environment and Safety) 1000 Navy Pentagon, Room 4A686 Washington, DC 203501000  ? Phone: (703) 6141304 hh#Fax: (703) 6952573 Ms. Molly Ross, Special Assistant to the Assistant Secretary Fish, Wildlife and Parks Service Department of Interior 1849 C Street N.W., M.I.B., Room 3150 Washington, DC 20240  ?X Phone: (202) 2086212hh#Fax (202) 2084684 Mr. James Shrouds, Chief Environmental Analysis Division Federal Highway Administration Department of Transportation, HEP40 400 7th Street S.W. Washington, DC 20590  ?`" Phone: (202) 3662076hh#Fax: (202) 3663409`"-)) Ms. Susan Studlien, Director Air Division Environmental Protection Agency, Region I JFK Federal Building Boston, MA 022030001  ? Phone: (617) 5653477hh#Fax: (617) 5654940 *Denotes CAAAC Membership@-))  ? #x6X@`7Q#X@#Z3ij.ATTACHMENT A6 MEMBERSHIP LIST COORDINATION AND WORK GROUPSZ  @page A-5-page A-6-@   HHXX  XX   `%%O *  ?   XXX   FACA Subcommittee Work Group Membership ă  ? " Working Draft 3/18/97 ă  ?@ LEGEND:` ` EX Environmental Groupsƀ%  ? XX` ` SX State and local agenciesƀ%  ? ` ` T Tribal representatives  ? XX` ` IX Industryƀ%  ?` XX` ` LX Lawyers/Consultantsƀ%  ?( XX` ` AX Academia/Scientificƀ%  ? XX` ` FX Federal Agenciesƀ%  ? ` ` O Other  ?   (f)denotes FACA subcommittee member  ?  Coordination Group hh#CoChairs: Sally Shaver ` `  hh#( Pat Raher, Hogan & Hartson (f)  ?  1. E` ` Thomas Godar, ALA (f)ƀ%`  ?  2. E` ` David Hawkins, NRDC (f)ƀ%`  ?  3. S` ` Mary Gade, IL EPA (f)ƀ%`  ?P  4. S` ` Robert Shinn, NJDEP (f)ƀ%`  ?  5. S` ` Beverly Hartsock, Texas (f)  ?  6. S` ` Bill Becker, STAPPA/ALAPCO (f)ƀ%`  ?  7. S` ` Jim Souby, Western Governor's Association (f)ƀ%`  ?p  8. T` ` Jerry Pardilla, NTEC (f)  ?8  9. I` ` Shawn Kendall, Phelps Dodge (f)ƀ%`  ? 10. I` ` Bradford Smith, Environmental Elements (f)ƀ%`  ? 11. I` ` Charles Goodman, Southern Co. (f)ƀ%`  ? 12. I` ` John Taunton, Exxon (f)ƀ%`  ?X 13. I ` ` Karl Schultz, DuPont (f)ƀ%`  ?  14. I` ` Richard Hayslip, Salt River Project (f)ƀ%`  ? 15. I` ` Georgia Callahan, Texaco (f)ƀ%`  ? 16. I` ` Tim OBrien, Ford Motor (f)  ?x 17. F ` ` Molly Ross, DOI (f)  ?@ 18. F` ` Susan Studlien, EPA (f)  ? 19. F` ` Gay MacGregor, EPA `".++  ? Science and Technical Support Group CoChairs: Tom Helms ` `  hh#(-Harvey Jeffries, UNC (f)  ?   1. E` ` Bruce Hill, Appalachian Mountain Club (f)ƀ%`  ?  2. S` ` Diana Andrews, Kentucky  ?  3. S` ` Kirit Chaudhari, Virginiaƀ%`  ?x  4. S` ` Tom Moore, Arizonaƀ%`  ?@  5. S` ` Rich Poirot, Vermontƀ%`  ?  6. S` ` S.T. Rao, NYƀ%`  ?  7. S` ` Manop Vanichchagorn, Louisianaƀ%`  ?  8. S ` ` Dave McNeil, Utah  ?`  9. S ` ` John Core, WESTAR  ?( 10. T` ` David Kelly, Navajo EPA  ? 11. O` ` Jeffrey West, NARSTONE  ? 12. I` ` John Cabaniss, AIAMƀ%`  ? 13. I` ` David Chock, Ford Motor ƀ%`  ?H 14. I` ` Jay Hudson, Santee Cooperƀ%`  ? 15. I` ` Steve Ziman, Chevronƀ%`  ? 16. I` ` Dan Weiss, Cinergy Corpƀ%`  ? 17. I` ` George Lauer, ARCO  ?h 18. A ` ` Ellis Cowling, NCSU  ?0 19. A` ` Jay Turner, Washington University  ? 20. A` ` Glen Cass, Cal Tech (f)  ? 21. A` ` Kenneth Demerjian, SUNYAlbany  ? 22. F` ` Mark Scruggs, DOI  ?P 23. F` ` Jay Rosenthal, DOD  ? Communications and Outreach Group CoChairs: Tom Curran XX` ` X XXhh#X( Ron White, ALAƀ%  ?  1. E` ` Jayne Mardock, Clean Air Network  ?  2. S` ` Tad Aburn, MDDEƀ%`  ?  3. S` ` Nancy Kruger, STAPPA/ALAPCOƀ%`  ?X  4. S` ` Bruce Carhart, OTCƀ%`  ?   5. S` ` Nancy Seidman, Massachusettsƀ%`  ?  6. S` ` Alice Collingwood, Puget Soundƀ%`  ?  7. S` ` Scott Thomas, Oklahomaƀ%`  ?x  8. T` ` Margaret Cook, Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc.  ?@  9. I` ` Quin Shea, Nat'l Mining Assocƀ%`  ? 10. I` ` Richard Paul, AAMAƀ%`  ? 11. I` ` Caryl Pfeiffer, Kentucky Utilities Coƀ%`  ?! 12. F ` ` Kathy Ellis, DOD  ?`" 13. F` ` Kathy Callahan, EPA #.++  ?  National and Regional Strategies Group CoChairs: David Mobley XX` ` X XXhh#X(X- Don Theiler, WIƀ%  ?   1. E` ` Nina Dougherty, Sierra Club  ?  2. E` ` Chris Shaver, EDF (f)  ?  3. E` ` David Marshall, Conservation Law Foundation (f)ƀ%`  ?x  4. S` ` Joe Belanger, Connecticut DEPƀ%`  ?@  5. S` ` John Leary, Western Governor's AssociationxxAƀ%x  ?  6. S` ` Timothy Method, Indianaƀ%`  ?  7. S` ` Terry Rowles, Missouriƀ%`  ?  8. S` ` Marvin Lowry, Georgiaƀ%`  ?`  9. S` ` Dan Johnson, Washingtonƀ%`  ?( 10. S` ` William Miller, Philadelphiaƀ%`  ? 11. S` ` Joe Francis, Nebraskaƀ%`  ? 12. S` ` Tom Wright, AAMVA  ? 13. S` ` Dewayne Huckabay, Houston  ?H 14. S` ` David Hyder North Carolina DOT  ? 15. S` ` Jason Grumet, NESCAUM  ? 16. T` ` Mike Frost, S. Ute Tribe  ? 17. I` ` Ted Wernick, Gillette Co. (f)ƀ%`  ?h 18. I` ` Sarah PeirceSandner, Kodak (f)ƀ%`  ?0 19. I` ` Lydia Salmon, Kenecott Copper Coƀ%`  ? 20. I` ` Amy Lilly, AIAMƀ%`  ? 21. I` ` Jon Heuss, General Motors Corpƀ%`  ? 22. I` ` Bruce Craig, NGSAƀ%`  ?P 23. I` ` Andrew Aitken, New England Power Service Coƀ%`  ? 24. I` ` John McManus, American Electric Power Coƀ%`  ? 25. I` ` Cliff Doumas, Mobilƀ%`  ? 26. I` ` Stan Hathcock, Webster South (f)  ?p 27. I` ` Mark Brownstein, Public Service Electric and Gas Co  ?8 28. I` ` Timothy Byrd, Gallo Winery  ? 29. I` ` Jerry Steffy, Harley Davidson  ? 30. L` ` Bob Wyman, Latham & Watkins (f)ƀ%`  ? 31. L` ` Larry Feldcamp, Baker & Botts (f)ƀ%`  ?X 32. A` ` Ted Russell, Carnegie Mellon (f)ƀ%`  ?  33. F` ` Donna Lamb, USDA/Forest Serviceƀ%`  ? 34. F` ` Dave Howekamp, EPA (f).++  ?  Base Program Analyses and Policies Group CoChairs: Joe Paisie XX` ` X XXhh#X(X- Jerry Golden, TVAƀ%  ?   1. E` ` Bob Palzer, Sierra Club (f)  ?  2. E` ` David Baron, Arizona Center for Public Law (f)  ?  3. E` ` William Luneburg, GASP (f)  ?x  4. S` ` Brock Nicholson, NCƀ%`  ?@  5. S` ` Dennis Lawler, IL EPAƀ%`  ?  6. S` ` Jim Salvaggio, Pennsylvaniaƀ%`  ?  7. S` ` Steve Gerritson, LADCO (f) ƀ%`  ?  8. S` ` Herb Williams Texasƀ%`  ?`  9. S` ` Mel Zeldin, South Coast, CAƀ%`  ?( 10. S` ` Rich Halvey, Western Governors Associationƀ%`  ? 11. S` ` Eric Skelton, Spokane Coƀ%`  ? 12. S` ` Jim Ralston, NYƀ%`  ? 13. S` ` Barbara Lee, N. Sonoma APCD  ?H 14. S` ` Arthur Marin, NESCAUM  ? 15. I` ` Vincent Brisini, Pennsylvania Electric (f)ƀ%`  ? 16. I` ` Richard Dworek, US Steel (f)ƀ%`  ? 17. I` ` Richard Phelps, Eastman Chemical Co. (f)ƀ%`  ?h 18. I` ` John Crouch, Hearth Products Assn.ƀ%`  ?0 19. I` ` Greg Schaefer, ARCOƀ%`  ? 20. I` ` Gregory J. Dana, AIAMƀ%`  ? 21. I` ` Steve Pezda, Fordƀ%`  ? 22. I` ` Jeff Gabriel, National Pork Producers (f)ƀ%`  ?P 23. I` ` Arthur Lee, Texacoƀ%`  ? 24. I` ` Robert Kappelmann, Jacksonville Electric Authority  ? 25. I` ` Richard Chastain, Southern Co. Services  ? 26. F` ` Jean Vernet, DOEƀ%`  ?p 27. F` ` Dick Schoeneberg, DOT  ?8 28. F.` ` Dick Long, EPA